V.com weekend vote: Do you use matching string sets?
Strings come in a set, but many of us don't always string our instruments with the same brand on for string.
For example, when I was growing up, I always used Dominants on everything except for the E, which was a Pirastro. More recently, I've used Evah Pirazzis on all but the G, for which I've used Infeld Red for that nice, warm sound.
Here is a 2005 discussion we had in which many people listed the strings that famous violinists use, though it's a bit out-of-date because Joshua Bell recently switched from Pirazzis to Jargar Superiors, a new kind of string.
Heifetz famously used a Goldbrokat Medium E, plain gut A and D, and a wound G.
Do you mix up the brands of strings that you use, or do you stick to one? And tell us about what you've tried and what you currently prefer!
Thank you to Morgan Watkins for this week's vote idea!
You might also like:
- Discussion: Strings used by famous violinists
- The Violinist.com Guide to Choosing Violin Strings
- Discussion: Gut Strings
Replies
Have taken to using Kaplan wound non-whistling E with Dominants on my violins although the latter's new tinned Es are nicely brilliant. On my tenor banjo the problem is finding a non-flabby G to go with an E unlikely to break when tuning. Still a work in progress.
I voted no strong preference, because I haven't given a solo performance for some years now, but if I were going to give one, I'd probably have Eudoxa on G and D, Eudoxa on A if it lasts, otherwise something synthetic, and probably Amber E (if it doesn't blend too badly - It'd be lovely to be without the whistle - and I'm referring to the sound, not the article of clothing).
I find that this combination works great for many instruments:
G - Vision (regular - not Solo or Titanium)
D - Dominant Silver (matches very well in color with Vision G)
A - Dominant
E - Goldbrokat extra heavy (28 gauge), or Jargar Forte if 28 is too much tension for the instrument.
G, D, and A are all medium gauge
Stick to one set for each violin.
I like the simplicity of using a whole set straight across, but I have been known to swap out the E for something better. When I order strings online, I just want to make one purchase, not four separate purchases. I think if the strings in the set don't work well together, than they aren't good strings.
I use one BRAND but different models... Also I am stringing each of three violins differently.
1) eudoxa E, obligato A & D, weich Evah Pirazzi G
2) Evah Pirazzi
3) Violino
Lately, all Helicore; but I want to try Thomastic Vision . . .
At present, I have a complete set of Evah Pirazzi Gold on my primary violin. I have the Gold G on that instrument, one of the options with this set, but I am still not absolutely certain that the G has quite the sound I am looking for. It is close though. There is a silver-wound G available in that set and I may try that next. My favorite string in that set is the E which is gorgeous. I have been very pleased with these strings. They stay tuned pretty well after roughly a week of breaking in. I will buy Evah Pirazzi Gold again when I purchase a new set in May.
My backup violin is a nice instrument, but played much less frequently. I have Vision Solos on the D, A, and E, and a regular Vision on the G string. It's a fine combination, but it does not excite my violin and I will likely try something else during my next string purchase. I am likely to go with Dominants on G, D, and A, with an Evah Pirazzi Gold E, which I am hoping might give me the sound that I want out of that instrument. For me, the Evah Pirazzi Gold E never whistles and sounds fantastic. If I could find an even better E, I'd buy it, but for now, this is my favorite. Any other suggestions for the world's best E?
I use a full set of Tonica and I love them for their perfect balance of warmth, brillance and projection. They have a wide range of colours, have worked well on every violin I've tried them on, and they're great value for money. Haven't tried much else, though. I'm very satisfied.
Note that Shar carries popular sets like Evahs with alternative E strings. So you can get the set price with the Goldbrokat E, for example.
I've used Evah Pirazzi for years but based on Ella's recommendation I might try the Tonicas. They're less than half the price of Evahs. Does anyone else recommend Tonicas too?
Apparently, the E-string in a set is substandard for many people and they replace it by something better. Since the string manufacturers know that, why don't they include a better E-string in their sets? For example Dominant. Is the Dominant E-string really that terrible? (I have never tried it, indeed I have never played with Dominants so far, strange as that may sound).
Why don't you try. I have never purchased Dominants, which may sound odd. Funny enough, Tonicas were the strings I discovered after using crappy metals for some time.
My recent delight: A matching set of Efrano gut strings heavy with copper wound G.
I play on Jargar Superior A, D, and G. I use a Westminster Starch E
This article has been archived and is no longer accepting comments.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Miroirs CA Classical Music Journal
Coltman Chamber Music Competition
Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins
Laurie's Books
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine
March 11, 2017 at 12:31 AM · I voted 3 -- "different brands for different strings; but 1 -- "single set for G, D, and A, but use a different E string" -- applies, too. I play on three older hand-made fiddles each day, about equal time on each. Current preferred setups, using three makers -- Lenzner, Thomastik, Pirastro:
1. 1921: E - Goldbrokat medium; A - Vision Solo; D - Peter Infeld aluminum; G - Infeld Red.
2. 1883: E - Goldbrokat medium; A - Passione regular; D-G - Eudoxa stiff.
3. 1869: E - Goldbrokat medium; A-D-G - Infeld Red.